Mafia 3: The Age of Turnip

##Vote Aaron

I have reason to believe we can trust William's judgement.

##VOTE AARON

As far as I can tell you guys are inches away from creating an unwinnable scenario for the town, though I suppose it depends how many scum there are. If that's what you want be my guest.

Well, don't vote the way I do just because I figured out Sin Spawn.

Definitely Town:
William Henderson
Timothy Henderson
R.U. Haydn
Alan Matherson

Mafia?
Brandon J. Thompson
Canton B. Arsedaton
Anthony Christopher Tucker, Jr.
Paul Turner

We need to figure out the best bet from those four. Aaron's an asshole, and while that turned out to work for SS, we have far less leeway here.

No, it's not just because you figured out Sin Spawn. Unless I'm actually interpreting things incorrectly here. Which actually seems as if it might be likely now. :/

I think you're right with Brandon as the godfather. It's an alternate to Aaron.

For what it's worth Shoy and Zack are probably my top two mafia suspects at the moment, with neobum being somewhat more distant third. Also Marick is dead so you can take him off your list. Is anyone else even still alive?

Use current names. Some of us aren't from this shit hole.

He probably mean R.U. Haydn. Damn confusing twin names.

Honestly, at the moment I'm working off assumptions based on observations. Which could be faulty. It's not something that's up to me to reveal, though.

Zack = Anthony Tucker, Marick = B.J. Haydn, Shoy = Brandon Thompson

When I started pointing fingers the mafia's way in that other game I got killed and they tried calling it a red herring. I'm not buying that. Time to find out whether my initial hunch was right.

##VOTE AARON.

Relying on meta is a pretty good way to lose the game.

Though if you have to rely on meta, consider that the mafia this game probably learned from the last game's mafia's failures. Killing the person who was on the right track rather than someone who was completely off the mark certainly didn't do the mafia any favours that game.

One other thing, though. I can't be sure unless I know if my earlier observation is correct or not, but if we're going to bring up past games there's a chance that Aaron might be a miller.

Is miller game speak for a bitch? I'm pretty much dead set on Aaron right now unless anyone has something better. He's said nothing but bullshit this entire game.

Alan Matherson wrote:

One other thing, though. I can't be sure unless I know if my earlier observation is correct or not, but if we're going to bring up past games there's a chance that Aaron might be a miller.

I'm starting to think that myself.

goatboy: Miller = comes up mafia when investigated, but is actually a vanilla townie.

Okay.

Votes needed to lynch: 5
Canton B. Arsedaton: 4 - William Henderson, Timothy Henderson, Alan Matherson, Paul Turner (L-1)
Players who need to vote: 6 - Canton B. Arsedaton, R.U. Haydn, Anthony Tucker, Brandon J. Thompson

##VOTE CANTON B. ARSEDATON

I'm unvoting Aaron until we talk more.
##Unvote Aaron.

I will still lynch him if possible.

Too late, once the last vote is cast, you can't retract your vote.

Canton B. Arsedaton wrote:

Alan Matherson wrote:

One other thing, though. I can't be sure unless I know if my earlier observation is correct or not, but if we're going to bring up past games there's a chance that Aaron might be a miller.

I'm starting to think that myself.

goatboy: Miller = comes up mafia when investigated, but is actually a vanilla townie.

"Starting to think that yourself"? If you were the miller it would say so in your profile.

Child Porn wrote:

Too late, once the last vote is cast, you can't retract your vote.

Uh, yes he can. Until I announce the night phase voting and unvoting can happen.

William Henderson wrote:

Mafia?
Brandon J. Thompson
Canton B. Arsedaton
Anthony Christopher Tucker, Jr.
Paul Turner

I get the same kind of feeling (except for me you jerk). I don't have full trust in Vink either just by virtue that I know he can play the role of Town quite well, but that could go either way.

Timothy Henderson wrote:

Canton B. Arsedaton wrote:

Alan Matherson wrote:

One other thing, though. I can't be sure unless I know if my earlier observation is correct or not, but if we're going to bring up past games there's a chance that Aaron might be a miller.

I'm starting to think that myself.

goatboy: Miller = comes up mafia when investigated, but is actually a vanilla townie.

"Starting to think that yourself"? If you were the miller it would say so in your profile.

Not necessarily, it depends on how the GM decides to run the game.

Is Abel playing? He hasn't been listed on any of AD's lists of people who need to vote.

Notice how everyone is just sort of ignoring him? Yeah.

Well ok I missed ADs post.

She still hasn't added him to "people who need to vote" though. Her list also says that six people need to vote, but only lists four.

If AD was going to add him she would have done it when he asked ages ago, not during the final leg of the game.